You are here :
Cleo home > Cleo News
Cleo News
homepage

Topless NZ Top Model complaint dismissed

By CLEO staff
13:00 AEST Mon Nov 29 2010
<i>New Zealand's Next Top Model</i>'s Michaela
New Zealand's Next Top Model's Michaela
Related articles

A complaint about an episode of reality television show New Zealand's Next Top Model in which contestants posed topless in a mud pool has been dismissed by the Broadcasting Standards Authority (BSA).

The episode, broadcast on TV3 in August, included shots of contestants posing for a female photographer, wearing bikini bottoms and accessories.

Some of the girls were topless but their breasts were covered in mud and concealed by steam from the pool.

16-year-old Michaela told the judges she was religious and "felt kind of bad".

"I don't think that's going to stop me from a lot of things as long as I have confidence in myself and confidence in the Lord," she said.

A viewer complained about the episode, saying she was "disgusted and disappointed to see a 16-year-old girl being exploited".

Broadcaster TVWorks said the contestants' comfort and wellbeing was taken very seriously.

"They have female chaperones with them 24 hours a day, their stylist on this particular occasion was a woman, as was the photographer.

"The models are free at any time to opt out of any situation with which they feel uncomfortable, so far this has not been the case."

The BSA ruled the nudity was effectively masked by the mud and did not breach standards of good taste and decency.

"No attention was drawn to her breasts; the transition between shots was relatively swift, and the camera tended to focus on the girl's face. We consider that the poses were non-sexual and were presented in an inoffensive way," it said.

New Zealand's Next Top Model interviews

New Zealand's Next Top Model face/off

Join us on Facebook

User comments
Those who run the show trying to copy world first class top model, eg - nudity and sexsual expression what make a top model popular, I believe we new Zealand top model can become world top model without sexsual expression and nudity photos. stone.
hahahaha you complain about the suggestion of breasts in a show that is obviously not what it claims to be. TOP MODEL?? what a joke. The girl that won it was not the best looking there and she knows it! The whole thing is just a political ploy. "The brown girl has to win this year!" and by the way, I am Maori so this is not a racist comment. So how can she represent NZ as an ambassador? She may be a lovely girl but she is out of her league to be considered the face of NZ. There is far more beautiful girls seen everyday in the streets of this country. Cultured ethnic girls, so I gotta ask, why this plain Jane? I will never watch the show again and I know a lot of other people that feel the same way! The whole thing was a farce!
Broadcaster TV Works said The models are free at any time to opt out of any situation with which they feel uncomfortable however, you can tell that the pressure they get from Sara and the other judges means they probably don't feel free to opt out without jeapordising their chances of winning.
Get over it. You didn't see anything. The person who made a complaint(s) is the sort of people who see sparks but yell 'fire'. There was nothing offensive about this at all.
Good grief, aren't we a touchy lot.
I was extremely disappointed that NZ Top Model would place such young girls in a compromising position. Anyone knows that despite what they claim, if they opted out they would have had no chance of another photo and been eliminated. It is sending the wrong message to those young girls in the competition and also viewing. I would hate my daughters to think that it was ok to display their bodies, even if it was in a professional environment. I'm very disappointed TVNZ and broadcasting standards. Shame on you for compromising our youngsters modesty
Accidentally deleted my 900 word comment! So here's the short version.. If the mud covered her..if the steam covered her..why was it nessessary to make the girls go topless? Jusifying your lack of morals and obvious lack of caring for the girls feelings, (not to mention her beliefs) will not save her from being dragged down a dark alley whenever a creep gets the opportunity. Here i go again..! As an attractive female,(so they say..) I have narrowly escaped being gang raped 3 TIMES!!! Just by walking down the street in jeans and t-shirt.. car loads of men WILL jump out and grab you. For girls that have been exposed.. Well..i can only imagine they will get it tenfold or more. Ask her in twenty years if it helped her career, or her pride. The answer will be no. (Unless your a prostitute, stripper, or sex worker of some kind.. it will always be no.) Just be honest.. sex sells.. and that's all that mattered. If only she knew how much money was made from her boobs. Way to manipulate her..
Ohh ...here we go again, the minority trying to dictate to the majority...hey viewer if you dont like what you see ...dont bloody watch ...pretty simple really..its not rocket science...no one was forced to do anything they didnt want to do..you bloody PC bunch are what is wrong with this country.
The girls are truly vulnerable and any complaint from them should be taken seriously. I can't imagine Michaela being free to walk out of a situation when her career is on the line, despite conflicts with her religious beliefs. Nudity is nudity, regardless of how one disguises it.
Of course the young girls are not going to opt out of the topless shot, as they know that this will have a negative effect on their potential career. Young girls like this, will feel tremendous pressure to do things beyond their comfort zone, and bordering on exploitation.

CLEO Magazinecleo magazine promotion

CLEO May is on sale with the fashionable Nicole Richie and a bonus SHOP mag featuring all the new season's fashion and beauty trends, how the coolest celebs wear them, and how you can too - even when you don't have Beyonce's budget.

advertisement


Horoscopes

  • dating
  • jobs